Sunday, January 04, 2009

The Swimmer: A Parable

A swimmer – a very strong swimmer – is churning through the ocean. He is such a strong swimmer that he seems oblivious to the huge millstone around his neck and even more gigantic anchor tied around his waist He swims towards what looks like an island in the distance – an island that appears to be coming rapidly closer. But it only appears to get closer because it is a cliff rising higher and higher out of the water. There is also a reef between him and the island – a reef that becomes ever larger and rockier.

As he swims, sirens in the water shout about what the swimmer is doing wrong and encourage him to get help from the jellyfish floating nearby. The sirens tell him to swim this way or that, and the jellyfish sting him if he doesn’t comply. Together, these groups keep adding weight to his anchor or his millstone – just to see if he can stay afloat. If one of our swimmer’s arms or legs tires, the sirens scream to the jellyfish, who attach a flotation device to that arm or leg. But they put a weight equivalent to that buoyancy on his opposite side. Each time the sirens and jellyfish do this, the reef gets bigger. The sirens warn of an imaginary maelstrom just ahead, and the jellyfish claim that the swimmer needs weight added to his anchor and millstone – ballast to get through the non-existent storm.

Our swimmer, such is his strength, has been going along fairly well until now. During the recent leg of his trip, the jellyfish have made the swimmer go this way and that, and they have added a little here and a little there to our swimmer’s burdens. Indeed, the swimmer is floundering now, and the sirens keep warning him to get more help from the jellyfish. All the while, the jellyfish keep adding to the reef the sirens keep ignoring the cliff. It doesn’t look good for the swimmer, who would have a hard time getting over the reef and climbing the cliff even without the heavy weights dragging him down.

The swimmer is the US economy. The anchor is the $3 trillion federal budget that is taken annually from the economy. The millstone is the additional weight of $1 trillion in regulatory costs. The sirens are our wonderful mainstream media, who just love the spineless jellyfish who are our elected officials. Both of these groups claim that the government can help the economy by taking something from one area to try to float another, while adding to the reef of national debt. The phony maelstrom is climate change (formerly known as global warming). Finally, the island in the distance is the implicit debt that future entitlements will cost – nearly $100 trillion in a few decades for the twin pyramid schemes of Social Security and Medicare.

If the sirens of the media actually cared about the swimmer, they would call for the congressional jellyfish to grow spines. A vertebrate Congress would lighten the swimmer’s tax and regulatory load so he could keep himself afloat. They would stop meddling by trying to float one side while sinking the other. They would grind down the reef of debt by avoiding deficit spending. They would admit that the climate changes all the time and that the earth has actually cooled off in the last decade, despite humans’ use of fossil fuels. And they would do something about the insurmountable cliff of New Deal and Great Society ripoffs. If the congressional coelenterates don’t do the right thing, our economy will sink, not swim. And, though they may not know it, the media sirens and bureaucratic jellyfish will go down with it.

Labels: ,

Are Social Security and Medicare Ponzi Schemes?

Chuck Asay’s recent cartoon implying that Social Security and Medicare are Ponzi schemes is an insult! How dare Asay besmirch the merely bad name of Ponzi by associating it with the truly monstrous pyramid schemes of FDR, LBJ and LBJ’s heir George W. Bush!

Ponzi was an honest swindler, and today’s Madoff is the same. These men merely lied and cheated to rip off unsuspecting investors. But they couldn’t force anybody into their trick plans the way our utterly corrupt political system can. And Ponzi accounting practices just cannot compare to the sham accounting of these government programs.

Here are some facts about these programs:

  • When Social Security began, there were 17 workers per retiree. Now, there are about 2.5, and the number of workers to retiree is still declining.
  • The original retirement age was set at 65, which was quite cynical, given that 1935’s life expectancy was 65.
  • More and more workers have been forced into the Social Security program. For example, certain Missouri public school employees are scheduled to be switched from their much better retirement system to Social Security. A pyramid scheme always needs more participants.
  • Medicare’s unfunded liability as of 2006 was $70 trillion in 2006; Social Security’s about $16 trillion. Taxes will go up and/or benefits will be reduced to sustain these con games.
  • As our benevolent government robs Peter to pay Paul, part of Paul’s money for Social Security and Medicare is actually being spent on other things. But not to worry, Paul, because the government leaves an IOU to itself for every dollar it diverts.
  • There are 65 million or so Baby Boomers. If, like me, you are one of these folks, be afraid, be very afraid, for you may not get what was promised. If you are younger, be afraid, be very afraid, for the Baby Boomers might get what was promised and you will have to pay for it.
Pyramid swindles? Definitely. But don’t call them Ponzi schemes. They are much worse than that.

Labels: ,